In brief, Situational Leadership means that you as a leader adapt your leadership style to the situation you're in. Meaning, if you're talking to person A, you adapt yourself to the preferences of person A. If you're talking to person B, you're adapting to person B. If person A is in situation X, you adapt to it. If person A is in situation Z, once again, you adapt to it.
In itself, a nice way to look at leadership. Because you, as a leader, always support your people in the way that fits best for them, and you give them exactly what they need at the time they need it most.
However -and this is the downside of it- it makes you, as a leader, a bit of a chameleon. You're constantly adapting to every person and every situation. Which sometimes can become confusing for the people around you: sometimes you react like this, and at others you react like that?!?
That's why the world of leadership slowly evolved into Authentic Leadership. Your predictability as a leader is very important to your peers and teammates.
So you, as a leader, should be able to be and remain your true authentic self. With the big benefit of being predictable.
We all know you have to repeat the same message multiple times before it really sticks in the ears of your audience. Well, with this form of predictability, your people know upfront how you're going to react to certain things, and it becomes crystal clear to them what is important to both you and the company. An ideal way to communicate and transfer your vision.
Sounds likes a brilliant thing, doesn't it?
But what if your true authentic self is not in line with what your people really need at a specific moment in time? (which was the big benefit of Situational Leadership)
That's why I personally, and we at The Happiness Factory in general, are more in favour of talking about Sincere Leadership.
A form of leadership where your leadership goals/purpose, your authentic self, and what is needed to get you and your team/company to that goal/purpose, all come together.
In short, let's call Sincere Leadership the result of the marriage between all beneficial elements of both Situational Leadership and Authentic Leadership.
I've already written more extensively about this form of leadership in these 2 blogs:
You definitely have to check them out if you want to learn more.
Or, if you're more of a visual and/or auditive person, get our Ambitious Leader Chat where Karolien and I talk about all the details of Sincere Leadership. Just express your interest here (Get access to our Ambitious Leader Chat about Sincere Leadership), and we'll send you the video!
Here's a 60 seconds preview of what to expect: